|
|
|
|
|
| |
| Issue 1, September/October 2005 |
| |
|
|
|
| En primeur tasting |
2004 Chablis |
| Tasting notes (notes on scoring unfinished wine) |
|
| |
| Key to quality assessment |
|
| |
| For wines tasted in cask or tank a description is used rather than a number for I feel that no wine should be given a definitive score before it is finished. My assessment of wine pre-bottling should be taken as impression of quality based principally on structure and extract and where possible the finer nuances. The reader should be aware that some wines will inevitably 'show' better than others at the time of tasting given the complications of tasting a wine going though malolactic fermentation (particularly applicable to the white wine in the next issue, as the malolatic of the 2004s was late for many producers), but also the great difference, in terms of accessibility for judging, just a few days can make to the same wine tasted on its lees, after racking, and after adding sulphur dioxide. |
| |
| The judgments include an assessment of typicité and fulfillment of appellation level. A premier or grand cru which drastically falls below expectation could conceivably be marked down to 14, and be outstripped by an excellent village wine which over delivers for its AC level. |
| |
Outstanding |
20 |
This should be a perfect wine within the context of the vintage. It should show great finesse and intensity on the nose. It should combine flair with perfect structure, serious complexity and superb potential for ageing. |
Very fine |
19 |
A notch below outstanding. Very fine with excellent extract and potential for ageing, but without the X factor - that extra level of finesse, elegance, depth or intensity which would lift it to outstanding. |
Fine |
18 |
A premium wine with fine structure. This level upwards in Pinot Noir should also exhibit an increasingly fine quality in tannins and texture. |
Particularly good |
17 |
Appealing harmony, firm concentration, decent definition and some complexity. Less layered than the wines above. This for example might be an outstanding village wine, or an agreeable, but not especially distinguished premier cru. |
Very good |
16 |
Expect to see increasingly well defined typicité from this level upwards and the capacity to develop (over the short term in this case). |
Good |
15 |
Correct but undistinguished. Good quality fruit, balance and skilful handing in the cellar, fulfilling reasonable expectations of appellation level and character but without the intensity and finesse of higher scoring wines. |
Very Attractive |
14 |
A modest but attractive wine, similar to the quality below - it may lack dimension, but has a more distinctive character. |
Pleasant |
13 |
Pleasant wine, but with no distinguishing character. Probably very accessible with modest intensity, decent varietal character and pleasing fruit. |
Very sound |
12 |
Marginally better than the basic minimum |
Sound, but simple |
10 |
Simple. The absolute minimum quality expected. Exhibiting sound winemaking, but lacking depth. |
Disappointing, faulty etc |
Below 10 |
Faulty, unbalanced, lacking concentration or something discordant or unpleasant |
|
| |
| Half point more indicated by + |
| |
| |
| |
| Tasting notes Chablis 2004 |
|
 |
These notes were taken in mid May 2005. In a few cases including Domaines Raveneau, René et Vincent Dauvissat and Christian Moreau Père et Fils a tasting of the 2003 had also been arranged and these notes have been included.
I also tasted mini-verticals back to 1999/98 of one cru from each domaine. These notes will appear soon. |
|
| |
| Domaine Jean-Claude Bessin |
|
Neat wines with a clear domain style. Very pure, flowery and subtle. Jean-Claude Bessin is a tall and kindly man. He thinks carefully about his wine. |
| |
| Chablis, 2004 |
| Vines are forty to fifty years old, no oak, fresh, clean and direct. Fruit driven aroma, moderate intensity, peachy and with quite a rounded palate. Fresh acidity, smooth texture, good balance, touch of apple and mineral. Subtle wine with moderate length. Good. From 2005/6 |
| |
| Chablis, Montmains, 2004 |
| Bessin made up a sample blend. Flowery, slightly mineral and nutty, (it was still on the lees in old barrels at this point). More depth and concentration than the previous wine, attractive fresh acidity, slightly honeyed, touch of cashewnut and a pleasant finish. Good+. From 2007/8 |
| |
| Chablis, Fourchaume, Vieilles Vignes, 2004 |
| Bessin did not make Fourchaume, La Pièce du Comte this year, but blended it with the older 50-75 year old vines. |
| Very pure and flowery with a touch of orange zest. Good attack. Lovely combination of honey and mineral. Light touch of new oak (10%). Very fresh and cool. Focused and crisp. Firm mineral finish. Particularly good to fine. From 2008/9 |
| |
| Chablis, Valmur, 2004 |
| 10% is fermentated in barrel giving a touch more wood on the nose, but very direct and pure, flowery and slightly stony. Silky textured, wet stone palate with racy acidity, lovely harmony and balance. Long elegant finish. This is a keeper. Fine to Very Fine. From 2010 |
| |
| Stockists |
UK: Fields, Morris & Verdin
USA: Kysela Père & Fils |
| |
| |
|
The chain cigar smoking, old school Bernard, and Samuel his robustly healthy, outdoor-type nephew make an unlikely team. From the fug of Bernard's office we moved to the pristine, modern stainless steel and glass cuvérie. I was proudly presented with something resembling a medical trolley on which I pushed my laptop from tank to tank. Samuel is very happy with the 2004s which he describes as, "classic, pure and typical. The wine of terroir." Bernard savoured each wine with his eyes closed and senses focused, murmuring gently to himself, "ah..très mineral, très mineral." Towards the end of the tasting he emerged out of his reverie and launched passionately into the importance of making classic wine. "Classic embodies the notion of history!" Furthermore...to paraphrase... only by respecting the traditional culture of winemaking can one guarantee the future of the classic style of Chablis and with this the very identity of the region. Benard's sentiments are eloquently expressed through Billaud-Simon's wine which is lucidly pure, classic and transparent to the terroir behind it. (Note in this assessment of domaine style that I did not taste viellies vignes Mont de Milieu and Blanchot which I gather are overtly marked by oak). |
| |
| Chablis, 2004 |
| Lovely aroma, very pure, bright citrus and deliciously fresh. Elegant and piercing acidity, taut, energetic, crisp and mineral. Good finish. A top notch, classic village Chablis. From 2006. |
| |
| Chablis, Tête D'Or, 2004 |
| This is vinified in 20% old wood. The Billaud-Simon team have just invested in new 600 litres oak cuves, but they are anxious that the new wood flavours of the oak do not show through. The following two samples, which will be blended, have the potential to make a fine quality village Chablis. Estimated drinking from 2007 |
| Oak cuve sample: Creaminess from the wood is apparent, but pure fruit shines though with wet stone minerality, herbal notes and a vibrant finish. |
| Tank sample: Excellent minerality, stony and racy with wonderfully taut fruit. Elegant and refined. Long. |
| |
| Chablis, Vaillons, 2004 |
| Floral, lifted and intense, greengages and citrus zest, but with some underlying earthy richness. Very focused fruit, taut and pure, with a stony fennel character. Long. Particularly good to fine. From 2008 |
| |
| Chablis, Mont De Milieu, 2004 |
| Richer and denser than the Vaillons, but with hints of flowers and gun-flint. Layered and structured on the palate, more depth and gravitas, tighter and gravely. Finishes on a fuller, fruitier but none-the-less direct note. Fine. 2008/9 |
| |
| Chablis, Montée De Tonnerre, 2004 |
| This will be a blend of individually fermented parcels of 85, 40, 20 year old vines. Bottling after 15 months. The elements are very promising. Particularly good to fine. From 2008/09 |
| 40 year old vines: Intense and rather steely aroma. Deep and direct, good grip and gunflint character. Long and linear. |
| 85 year vines: Somewhat richer, broader and rounded with very steely acidity and a powerful finish. |
| |
| Chablis Vaudesir, 2004 |
| Elegant floral aroma, refined and feminine with vervy minerality. More quartzy mineral and less steel, delicate, but intense. Glassy transparency and finesses. This should age well. It's not quite so obvious, but I like it very much. Very fine. From 2010 |
| |
| Chablis, Les Preuses, 2004 |
| Old vines of 60 years. Not forthcoming on the nose, but like a coiled spring. Fine polished texture and stony fruit. Poised and cool with great balance and intensity and a sustained linear finish. Fine. From 2012 |
| |
| Chablis, Les Clos, 2004 |
| 60 year old vines. This is rich, golden and profound with splendid glossy minerality. More sensual than the Preuses. Dense and complete with a mouth filling spherical structure and a powerful finish. Fine, probably very fine, but I prefer the Vaudesir. From 2010/11 |
| |
| Stockists |
UK: H & H Bancroft; Bentalls of Kingston; Berry Bros and Rudd; Ian G. Howe; Longford Wines; Montrachet; Freddy Price; Selfridges; Charles Taylor Wines; Wine Trading Co; The Wine Society; Noel Young Wines.
USA: Garnet Wines and Liquors; Hi-Time Wine Cellars; Langdon Shiverick Inc. |
| |
| |
| Domaine Christophe & Fils |
|
Thirty year old Sébastien Christophe studied in Beaune and set up as a vigneron in 1999. His grandfather was a farmer and the family own extensive, designated, but mainly unplanted property including 25 hectares of Petit Chablis. In 2000 Christophe planted some Petit Chablis, but he also has some older vines including premier cru Fouchaume which is owned in conjunction with his uncle. The vines are 25 years old. Christophe vinifies everything in stainless steel and is determined to maintain what he classifies as a pure terroir approach. Tasting confirmed a classic style from this domaine. |
| |
| Petit Chablis, 2004 |
| Promising start from young vines. Bright, fresh and slightly herbal. Rather light, but zesty and pure. Sound. Drink when bottled. |
| |
| Chablis, 2004 |
| Two parcels of vines near Fyé, 25 and 6-8 years old. Pure, floral and lively. Delicate mineral notes on this wine. Crisp, glassy and with decent grip and typicity. Very to particularly good. From 2005/6. |
| |
| Chablis, Vieilles Vignes, 2004 |
| The vines are 46 years old and lie above Fauchaume with another parcel above Les Clos. |
| Attractive clarity, vivacious and pure with decent grip. More intensely fruity. More compact in the middle palate, focused and linear and with better defined minerality. Top notch village wine. From 2006/7 |
| |
| Chablis, Fouchaume, 2004 |
| Broader more intense aroma. Fuller but with vibrant mineral backbone. Racy style with excellent clarity. Good, but not as good as the viellies vignes An impressive start with this wine. From 2007 |
| |
| Stockists |
UK: AB Vintners. |
| |
| |
Domaine Jean Collet & Fils |
|
Gilles Collet was just nineteen in 1987 when he took control of the family business. Although he is the third generation to have bottled the wine, his maternal grandmother's family have been growers since 1910. Collet says he has changed nothing in the way his father produced wine. His objective is to produce a typical Chablis with terroir taste. He is an exceedingly genial man who loves working with the wine, but also takes great pleasure in contact with his customers. He is married to Dominique who brought her family's vineyard property into the Collet fold. There is a blend of traditional and modern approaches in this winery with oak fudres and high tech tanks. This tasting reveals sound well made wines with good typicity. |
| |
| Petit Chablis, 2004 |
From a single vineyard in Villy inherited from Dominique's parents. |
| Vibrant citrus aroma with a fresh, attractive and lively palate, simple but shows good typicity. Very sound. From release. |
| |
| Chablis, 2004 |
| This is a blend of fruit from Villy and Prehy and from vines behind Montée de Tonnerre and in front of Vaillon. Each is vinified separately and then blended and kept on fine lees. |
| Straighforward, very fresh and juicy with zippy acidity, light and fresh. Attractive. Drink on release and for a couple of years. |
| |
| Chablis, Vieilles Vignes, 2004 |
The fruit comes from a single hectare parcel of vines in excess of 70 years near Villy inherited from Dominique's grandmother. |
| Lovely greengage fruit with touch of honey. Somewhat fuller and richer than the straight Chablis with more grip on the back palate, a longer finish and more evident minerality. Good. Drink from 2006 |
| |
| Chablis, Montmains, 2004 |
This combines a slight mealy character with floral notes. Silky first impression, followed by plenty of bite. Vigourous acidity, taut and somewhat nervy with a direct finish. Decent depth and linearity. Very good. From 2008 |
| |
| Chablis, Vaillons, 2004 |
| Carries the wood unintrusively on the nose. More apparent on the palate. Plump and rounded, slight mealiness, but also a touch of wet stone. Quite refined with more than decent acidity and length which has a mineral bite. Particularly good. From 2007/8 |
| |
| Chablis, Montée De Tonnerre, 2004 |
| Spice on the nose with tight citrus charcters. Good attack and quite a lot of grip on the back palate. Very juicy acidity. Taut wine with decent polish on the texture. Quite a generous finish, but not quite enough Montée de Tonnerre identity or focus. Very to particularly good, but I prefer the wine above. From 2007/8 |
| |
| Chablis, Valmur, 2004 |
Use of 2, 3 and 4 year old wood. Slightly spicy and a touch exotic on the aroma. More gravitas and depth to this wine with a rich and plump middle palate. Powerful finish. Definitely a step up in concentration, but I still prefer the style of Vaillons. Particularly good+. From 2009/10 |
| |
| Stockists |
UK: Heath Street Wine Co.; Ian G. Howe; Laytons; Le Picoleur; La Réserve; Le Sac à Vin.
USA: Robert Chadderdon Selections; Garnet Wines & Liquors. |
| |
|
Thierry Mothe is one of three brothers involved in Domaine du Colombier. Vincent works in the vines and Thierry makes the wine, which has a delicate almost fragile quality. This is very appealing given that the wines are also competently made with well-tuned balance and pure fruit. Not 'great' wines, but undeniably charming and with a clear domaine style. Mothe instigated changes when he took over from his father. He favours cool 17 degrees fermentation. He likes the control of inoculating to start the fermentation and malolactic. His latest innovation is to bring oak into the curvérie. He tells me that he believes passionately in the land, in the vine and in respecting nature. "I want to respect terroir and Chablis's minerality." I like his wines but I am not convinced, based on the sample of Bougros I tasted, that their pure and delicate style needs embellishing with oak. |
| |
| Petit Chablis, 2004 |
| Pretty aroma, fruit driven and flowery. Fruity palate, forward and well balanced. Simple, but with an appealing style. Pleasant. Should be ready on release. |
| |
| Chablis, 2004 |
Pure fruit with lively aromatics of greengages, white flowers and nettles. The palate is juicy yet delicate, vivacious and well balanced. Very good. Drink soon after release. |
| |
| Chablis, Vaucoupin, 2004 |
| Pure and clear with appley and blossomy aromas and a bit more intensity and palate weight. Elegant, lively style with dinstinct minerality on the moderate finish. Cool, refreshing and well made. Very good. From 2007 |
| |
| Chablis, Fourchaume, 2004 |
35 year old vines. Richer and more generous on the aroma, but still light and delicate. Somewhat broader palate, more density in the middle. Lovely pure fruit combined with nervosity and slight flint. Excellent balance. Very to particularly good. 2008/9 |
| |
| Chablis, Bougros, 2004 |
| The blended wine will be two thirds cuve and one third barriques. The vines are approaching sixty years old. |
| |
Sample one in tank: Glossy aroma. Excellent palate coverage. While a little bit more plump it shows a light touch. Definitely a more complete wine. Good stony backbone to balance the richer fruit. Very neatly made. Particularly good to fine. 2009/10 |
| |
Sample two: Portion fermented in wood. Toastier on the nose. As expected the oak adds some opulence and creamy texture to the palate. Well handled. Very good. |
|
| Stockists |
UK: Continental & Overseas Wines; Fields Wine Merchants; Goedhuis & Co.
USA:
Vineby Gerard, NY. |
| |
Domaine De La Conciergerie |
|
| Chablis, 2004 |
Muted smoky and saline aroma. Modest attack with a light saline character and low toned fruit on the middle palate. Earthy intensity and a reasonable finish for village Chablis. Sound. Bottled and ready. |
| |
| Chablis, Veilles vignes, 2004 |
Fifty-two year old vines in 3 parcels. More weight on the aroma and concentration. More gravelly character than the saline of the straight Chablis. Creamy texture and quite a lot of grunt on the middle and back palate. Although this is denser, I tend to prefer the purity of the wine above. Sound. From 2006 |
| |
| Chablis, Côte De Cuissy, 2004 |
More pronounced saline character here, also a touch floral. Quite low and earthy toned. Moderate density on the middle palate, with a certain breadth and balancing firm acidity. Modest finish. Very sound. From 2006 onwards. |
| |
| Chablis, Montmain, 2004 |
Upright aroma with more stone character. Reasonable fruit quality here, ripe with plumpness in the middle palate, with moderately gravelly character and a fairly decent finish. Fairly good. From 2006 |
| |
| Chablis, Butteaux, 2004 |
More restrained than the Montmains on the aroma. Showing more complexity, layers and terroir character. Again quite gravelly and with more grip and a firmer, better sustained finish. Good. From 2006 |
|
| Stockists |
UK: Laytons
.
USA:
Vigneron Imports. |
| |
|
Daniel Dampt makes a very pure fruit style, almost glassy with a crisp modern touch. These are elegant, transparent and vibrant wines which may not show much in youth, but don't be deceived, they blossom with age. Impeccably made.
Dampt emphasises that he always chooses the date of harvest by the acidity levels rather than sugar. "We need the acidity for the evolution and the freshness of the wine." He bottles really quite early to retain this freshness. Beauroy, was the first premier cru to be bottled, (15 th March). It's notable how lime green these wines are. |
| |
| Chablis, 2004 |
The vines come from many different parcels and the vines are between 10-60 years old for this generic Chablis. Dampt prefers not to make a vielles vignes but to blend older and younger vines to ensure consistency.
|
| Lime-fresh aromtics. Very clean, pure, direct and minerally style. Neat and impectably made. Very good for basic Chablis. From 2006/7. |
| |
| Chablis, Beauroy, 2004 |
An ethereal, intense but quite delicate aroma. Full appley character on the palate. (The soil is very fine clay). Quite tight and racy. Although the acidy is balanced, it is not notably high. Supple and sustained. Very good. From 2008 |
| |
| Chablis, Fourchaume, 2004 |
Very reserved aroma, not showing much, but unsprung, not lacking in substance. Good attack and more open on the palate. Fennel and apple. Medium and rounded body yet with firm structure and a moderate follow through. More immediate than the following premier crus. Particularly good. From 2007/8 |
| |
| Chablis, Vaillons, 2004 |
| This comes from a number of lieux-dits each with slightly different terrior which Daniel Dampt feels sure contributes to complexity. Very new botting, so a little lean on the aroma. Light apple and mineral. Smooth and sophisticated attack with full apple flavours and a steely backbone. Dense middle palate and more energetic than the Fauchaume. Firm and sustained. Zesty finsh. Particularly good to fine. From 2008/9 |
| |
| Chablis, Les Lys, 2004 |
"The soil analysis for Vaillons and Les Lys is the same, but the wines are always different."
|
| Slightly more flowery than Les Lys. It is pure, direct and tight with a chalky character. Intense appley attack, steely and austere, but with white flowers and lime fruit. Rather refined. Will fill out with time. Delicate, long and intense finish. Fine and stylish wine. From 2009 |
| |
| Chablis, Côte De Lechet, 2004 |
Not giving a lot away on the aroma. Slight smoke and white flowers. Minerality defines the palate, racy, linear and taut with hint of fennel. I like the focus on this wine. It has a well sustained flinty finish. Very poised and should age elegantly and for a long time. Particularly good to fine. From 2010 |
| |
| Stockists |
UK: Ballantynes of Cowbridge; Georges Barbier of London; Haynes, Hanson, Clark; Playford Ros Ltd.; Waters of Coventry. The Vine Trail.
USA:
T. Edward Wines; Michael Skurnik Wines Inc.; Vinalia
|
| |
Domaine René & Vincent Dauvissat |
|
Vincent Dauvissat produces racy, nervous wines of excellent quality. They have a wonderful clarity and are composed of clean, fine and 'simple' lines. In equine terms they are flighty Arabs to Raveneau's sleek Thoroughbreds.
The conditions in 2004 were good says Dauvissat, but he remarks that it was big vintage with which he is evidenty not that comfortable. However his vines are old and do not over yield, and he seems relatively satisfied that the grapes were well-ripened. He never does a green harvest. Harvesting is by hand, followed by whole bunch pressing. Dauvissat takes a very simple approach, keen to preserve the real work carried out in the vineyard. There is always a malolactic here, even in 2003, and the wine rests on fine lees until bottling.
Vincent Dauvissat generally didn't need to acidity in 2003. Only two of his cuvées were adjusted. He was confident that the terroir/mineral character would suffice. |
| |
| Petit Chablis, 2004 |
The vines come from a parcel above Les Clos on the plateau behind the wood.
|
| Gently floral and upright with delicate minerality. Appears light to begin with, but fills out through the well balanced palate. Sea-shell notes on a finish which is well very sustained for a Petit Chablis. From 2006 |
| |
Petit Chablis, 2003 |
Energetic with hints of kerosene on the bouquet. It is reminiscent of an older Riesling on the palate, firm acidity, quite austere aquiline structure and a decent finish. Drink now. |
| |
| Chablis, 2004 |
Vines are on the opposite slope to Les Forêt, facing North West.
|
| Pure and classic aroma, very straight and reserved. Direct, no nonsense palate, mineral, refreshing, restrained and linear. The finish is notably sustained for generic Chablis and attractively chalky. Top notch for straight Chablis. From 2007 |
| |
| Chablis, 2003 |
| This was picked on the 9 th September. Herbal, nutty, keroscene character, rich but direct. Rather austere and reticient on the palate, chalky and tense. Excellent for a generic Chablis in this vintage. From 2006/7. |
| |
| Chablis, Sechet, 2004 |
This was fermented half in old wood and half in tank. Dauvissat comments that the hard and chalky soil gives the wine its nervosity. It will not be bottled until December.
|
| Complex aroma with notes of honey, anise and apple blossom, both reserved and delicate. Quiet entry on the palate with herbal characters. Direct and linear form, racy, edgy and austere. Very long and chalky palate, but with suppleness on the finish. Very neatly made. Fine. From 2009/10 |
| |
Chablis, Sechet, 2003 |
Lifted, vigourous and nervous aroma. Focused palate, taut as a spring, tense with chalky, oyster shell character. Very austere, more minerality than acidity. Delicious and captivatingly edgy for this vintage. Fine. From 2008 |
| |
| Chablis, Vaillons, 2004 |
| Dauvissat has 1.4 hectares of premier cru Vaillons. The soil is deep and the slope steep. The wine has a very different shape to the Sechet on nose and palate. It smells of a sea-beaze, before opening to more rounded apricot and fennel aromas. The palate has a wet stone smoothness and coolness. It's firm but spherical, svelt and rather subtle. Fine to very fine. From 2010 |
| |
| Chablis, Vaillons, 2003 |
Rich and rather honeyed on the aroma with exotic blossomy notes, but very contained. Round, smooth and glossy, but with an energetic core running through this. Compact and polished. Fine to very fine. From 2008/9 |
| |
| Chablis, La Forêt, 2004 |
| 4.5 hectates of La Forêt which Dauvissat describes as complex argile (clay), some of it quite deep. |
| Rather coquettish wine. Silky, seductive fruit on the aroma, yet somehow reserved. Ampleness on the front and middle palate, which cloaks the acidity and a stony, oyster-shell core. Hints of bitter almond and a persistent minerally finsh. Nervy, linear and focused. A little plumper in the middle than the Sechet, but not as smooth and rounded as the Vaillons. Fine. From 2009 |
| |
| Chablis, La Foret, 2003 |
Supple, seductive aroma with hints of cashew. Stony and oyster-shell character combined with biscuity notes. Silky, but compact texture. Inviting but refined and composed. Fine. From 2007 |
| |
| Chablis, Les Preuses, 2004 |
Dauvissat likens the site of Les Preuses to an amphitheatre exposed East and South East so that it receives the morning sun. The vines' roots, he comments, penetrate through the surface fractures deep into the subsoil.
|
| Intense and elegant. Flowery, apple blossom and white flowers. Silky, powdery, very pure and poised. Linear and direct profile, but with depth and richness. A very classic profile, less edgy, more dignified, but still vervy. It manages to be both subtle and intense. Persistent flinty and chalky follow through. Quite delicious and possibly my favourite wine of the trip. Outstanding. From |
| |
| Chablis, Les Clos, 2004 |
1.7 hectares planted with 48 year old vines. Dauvissat describes the soil as very homogenous (like the wine it produces), deep, lots of argile, very compact and dense.
|
| Complex aroma which is not easy to penetrate. It is very compact at the moment. Suggestion of gun-flint. Very complete and rounded palate with power and density. Taut and mineral but with an overlying glossy texture. Very polished wine, more overt than Les Preuses and more spherical. Serious finish. Outstanding wine. Although this is more profound and arguably more complex than the Preuses, I prefer the style of the latter. From 2012 |
| |
| Chablis, Les Clos, 2003 |
Edge of opulence here, but as ever with Dauvissat's wine, coupled with reserve. Svelte, rounded and deep, with an energetic core and glossy minerality. Very well balanced, if a bit weightier on the back palate than the 2004. More broadly aristocratic. More sexy and ample than the Preuses, but never-the-less it tightens to an excellent, focused mineral finish. 2009 Very fine to outstanding . |
| |
| Stockists |
UK: Domaine Direct; Justerini and Brookes
USA:
Vineyard Brands |
| |
Domaine Jean-Paul & Benoit Droin |
|
Benoît Droin is a dynamic and talented young vigneron, keen to experiment and to push the boundaries. He has already made significant changes to this father's methods, beneficially pulling back the use of oak. There is not such a strong sense of domaine style here as Droin deliberately uses winemaking techniques to emphasise the character of each cru. Because the crus are both so individual and different in style, it's impossible to like everything in Droin's portfolio as is sometimes possible with other domaines. Each premier and grand cru is a 'love it or hate it' wine. |
| |
| Petit Chablis, 2004 |
One parcel of vines above the grand cru, beyond the trees line. Portlandian soil.
|
| Light and pure. Bright citrus fruit and a touch saline on the finish. Pleasant. Drink soon. |
| |
| Chablis, 2004 |
Droin uses only stainless steel for the Chablis.
|
| Pure aroma and quite refined. Zesty citrus, forward and fruity, medium bodied and with a fair mineral finish. Attractive. From 2006 |
| |
| Chablis, Les Vaillons, 2004 |
For this cuvée Droin uses 25% of barrels which are new to 4 years old.
|
| Reserved, floral aromatics although the wood is a touch dominant at the moment. Good style and fruit concentration, but perhaps lacks a little finesse. Good. From 2007 |
| |
| Chablis, Vaucoupin, 2004 |
Since 2000 Droin has changed the treatment of this wine significantly. One hundred percent wood has been reduced to 100% stainless steel in 2004. His objective? "To preserve the minerality."
|
| Chalky, powdery and apple blossom aroma. Tense attack, followed by a very focused palate. Taut middle and linear follow through. Citrus and crystalline with a very persistent finish. Elegant wine. Very to particularly good. From 2008. |
| |
| Chablis, Côte De Lechet, 2004 |
Powdery, stony aroma. Tense attack followed by a compact palate and linear form. Streamlined. Reserved and not showing much mineral at present. Hints of fennel and chalk. Finishes well. Particularly good. From 2008 |
| |
| Chablis, Vosgros, 2004 |
Thirty percent of old wood which Droin tells me he uses to make the wine more accessible as it can be very backwards before it begins to show its minerality. Never-the-less this is still quite austere and restrained on the nose. The earthy and tense palate is also quite shy. Touch of Riesling-like petrol which (I am told) is a character associated with Droin's older Vosgros. Very reserved, but power and concentration behind. Broad, masculine, tense and structured with notes of chicory. Needs a lot of time. Of very good quality but a bit of an ugly youth at the moment. From 2009 |
| |
| Chablis, Montmains, 2004 |
| Lots of peachy open fruit with obvious creamy oak. The oak gives it a sweetness and accessibility. Fruity and quite plump to start with but tightens up on the palate to a well focused, chalky and moderate finish. Very agreeable. Slighty flirty and come hither in comparison with the others in the flight. A little unusual for Montmains. Very to particularly good. From 2008 |
| |
| Chablis, Fourchaume, 2004 |
Droin favours more oak in this cru as he considers his parcel rather Côte d'Or in style. However he has ,pulled back from the quantity used by his father. Fifty percent is now used of which 10% is new. Sweet creamy vanilla aromas with peachy, quite rich fruit. Supple texture, rounded, perhaps bordering on the voluptuous for Chablis. The wood makes this naturally more generous cru somewhat flashy. While I am not greatly in favour of this style it is of very good quality. From 2009 |
| |
| Chablis, Mont De Milieu, 2004 |
This is still quite a new cru for Droin, although the vines are old. |
| Lime leaves on the aroma, blossomy floral and intense. This wine is a bit of a dicotomy. Feminine aroma while having a powerful, more masculine profile on palate. Droin has actually bumped up the level of 2-3 year old oak to 25%, and it's an example of well handled wood. On the palate there is full apple fruit coupled with steely austerity, and there is more focus and concentration than the Fourchaume. Dense middle palate with a great follow though. This should age well. Fine possibly very fine. From 2010 |
| |
| Chablis, Montée De Tonnerre, 2004 |
| Very fine, chalky, powdery, saline and vibrant. Lovely purity. This is vinified in 25% wood, of which only a little is new. Tight and steely-strong wine. Focused and compact palate. Profile is clearly defined and shows flair. Chalky taut piano wire finsh. Fine. I like this wine. From 2008. |
| |
| Chablis, Blanchot, 2004 |
| Droin has drawn right back - no oak at all. Steely and ever so slightly fragrant. Unusually for Blanchot this is nervous, delicate, flighty, yet calms down to a tight grippy mid palate and lovely chalky finsh. Like the verve here. Paticularly good, possibly even fine. 2008 |
| |
| Chablis, Valmur, 2004 |
35% wood is used on this cru of which one third is new. Since 2002 Droin has been developing his interpretation of Valmur. He tells me that he is looking for smoky and malt whisky aromas with Chassagne character. Well there's certainly quite a lot of wood on the nose with a dark spice character, but behind this there are also more interesting flinty aromatics. The palate is broad, bordering on slightly square and clumpy in comparison with the Blanchot - more savoury and masculine. Blokey wine. Not my style, but never-the-less the quality is particularly good. From 2010 |
| |
| Chablis, Vaudésir, 2004 |
This has the same wood treatment as Valmur, but incorporates the wood much more elegantly. Certainly it is powerful, dense and rich, but also more harmonious. It has a steely backbone, very stony and mineral with a touch of chicory flavour. Strong wine with a compact core, direct profile and impressive follow through. Very expressive and energetic. Despite the wood this is quintessential Chablis. Very fine. From 2010 |
| |
| Chablis, Grenouilles, 2004 |
As with the Fauchaume, Droin has lowered the percentage of wood from 100% to 55%. He feels that the style is not very mineral, and he would rather emphasise the richness.
|
| Rather earthy, creamy, nutty, marked wood on the nose, though not overpowering. Quite a subtle attack for what is a rich and powerful wine showing the concentration of old vines. Very masculine, aggressive, compact and it must be said 'angry' wine at the moment. Droin made sample blends of the grand cru for this tasting and perhaps this is suffering from the handling. Broad, but lots of grip and packs a massive punch. Long sturdy finish. Very different style, not particularly subtle, but of particularly good quality. From 2010/12 |
| |
| Chablis, Les Clos, 2004 |
Droin use 55% wood of which 25% is new.
|
| Giving very little on the nose, tight and terse. Palate intensely powerful, flinty, silex and oyster shell flavour. Much more mineral backbone than the Grenouilles and more complex. Dense palate, huge reserves to this wine, just seeing the tip of the iceberg. Very architectural with a serious finish. Fine to very fine. From 2010/12. |
| |
| Stockists |
UK: Berry Bros & Rudd; Bidendum; Domaine Direct; Goedhuis & Co.; Harrods; Ian G. Howe; Raeburn; Richards Walford.
USA: Block Distribution; Direct Import Wines; European Cellars; Grape Expectations, Hi-time Wine Cellars; Roanoke Valley Wine; Santé Wine Distribution; The Henry Wine Group; USA Wine; Western Importers.
|
| |
| |
|
Domaine Drouhin is a substantial landholder in Chablis and works its vineyards organically. The fruit for Domaine de Vaudon comes from the vineyards abutting the premier crus of Montée de Tonnerre and Mont de Milieu. The vines are about thirty years old.
|
| Drouhin's Chablis is rather opulent given the wood treatment and ripe concentrated fruit. It will find much favour among those looking for a rich and more Côte d'Or style of Chablis. Good and consistent quality. |
| |
| Chablis, 2004 |
Marked oak on the nose, but attractive, ripe fruit underneath. Firm palate, ample body, rich texture and just a touch of minerality. Pleasant, well balanced wine, if not particularly typical. From 2006. |
| |
| Chablis, Domaine De Vaudon, 2004 |
Lovely, lively and floral with much more steely intensity. Tight and muscular on the front palate, firm backbone and showing fair breadth. Big step up from the former Chablis. Very good. From 2007 |
| |
| Chablis, Premier Cru, 2004 |
Softly fragrant and flowery with a zesty citrus follow though on the aroma. Although the oak is very apparent at this stage, there is a generous mouth feel, dense fruit and lively acidity. Fairly good. From 2007 |
| |
| Chablis, Montmains, 2004 |
Waxy, a little honeyed, soft and flowery. Surprisingly, given the aroma, quite a masculine profile, broad, good grip, dense fruit and gravelly minerality. Firm structure for aging. Long, fairly meaty finish. Particularly good. From 2008 |
| |
| Chablis, Vaillons, 2004 |
Somewhat exotic, lychee fruit, appealing. Rounded, yet compact palate with excellent dense fruit. Showing the framework of the wood at the moment. Creamy texture and a thorough finish. Particularly good, but the Montmains has the edge on structure in this vintage. From 2010 |
| |
| Chablis, Les Clos, 2004 |
Very Côte d'Or style. Rich, velvety texture and intense fruit. Aristocratic and controlled with a serious framework. Opulence combined with vibrancy. An impressive finish. Fine. From 2010 |
| |
| Stockists |
UK: Contact the agents: Dreyfus Ashby. Ballantynes of Cowbridge; Decorum Vintners; Lea & Sandeman; James Nicholson Wine Merchants; Howard Ripley; Roberson Wine Merchant Ltd; Stones of Belgravia.
USA:
Dreyfus Ashby & Co.; Garnet Wines & Liquors; Hi-Time Wine Cellars; Sherry-Lehmann Inc. |
| |
|
Gérard Duplessis racks only once and then holds the wine in bottle before release. This is sensible as the Domaine style is ultra reserved. Take Fourchaumes for example - this typically generous cru is very controlled at Domaine Duplessis. Linear wines with pure fruit and good mineral profile. The best wine will take time to show their true character. |
| |
| Chablis, 2004 |
| Lightish, appley and floral. Slight minerality and citrus wine. With a modest finsh. Sound. From release. |
| |
| Chablis, Montée De Tonnerre, 2004 |
| Slightly more density on the nose with touch of saline. A very even palate, pure and quite poised. A linear profile with a good mineral finish. Very good. From 2007/8 |
| |
| Chablis, Montmains, 2004 |
| Vigorous wine, particularly zesty and racy with fine linear structure, powdery texture and chalky finish. Very reticient. Particularly good. From 2007/8. |
| |
| Chablis, Vaillons, 2004 |
Saline and quite intense and lifted. Very taut and stony with chalky acidity. It is very finely textured with a smoothness and a long limestone finish. A very linear Vaillons with fine clarity. Particularly good. From 2009 |
| |
| Chablis, Fourchaumes, 2004 |
Lifted, elegant and fragrant aroma with white blossom. More gloss on the attack and richness with slight plumpness on the middle palate. Linear style though with depth and intensity. Lovely clarity of fruit and quite a powerful mineral finish. Particularly good, possibly fine. From 2009 |
| |
| Chablis, Les Clos, 2004 |
Very hidden, but promising aroma with just a hint of the minerality. Good attack, immediate intensity, and surprising power and density on the middle palate and finish. Very pure and linear with earthy stone and saline character. Clear step up from the previous wines and shows good focus, energy and grip. Dignified wine. Particularly good to fine. From 2010. |
| |
| Stockists |
UK: Richards Walford.
|
| |
| |
|
1998 was Didier Séguier's first vintage at Fèvre. He arrived with the Henriot team, before which he worked with Bouchard. Séguier's ambition was to return Fèvre to focus on terroir and to create "an identity more precisely related to the vineyard." He discontinued the use of new oak and now uses only older oak. He is meticulous in the cellar and is particularly concerned with ensuring that the must is as clean as possible. This he achieves via careful selection of fruit and a long cold déboubage - settling by gravity.
|
| Didier Séguier was keen to convey that Fèvre has significant vineyard holdings; 15.2 hectares in total. This includes 12 hectares of premier cru and 20 of Chablis, making it largest producer of premier and grand cru. The average age of the vines is 30-40 years old, the best part of which was planted at the end of the Fifties and beginning of Sixties by Monsieur Fèvre. |
| The style of wine is clinically precise. Probably due to the super-clean juice, the unfinished wines are among the hardest to assess. Their expression is muted, although their structure is technically accomplished and shows good potential. Sadly at the time Fèvre presented no older wine with which to illustrate how their wines develop. I hope to do a vertical tasting at some point and report later this year. |
| |
| Saint-Bris, 2004 |
Mr Fèvre started this 21 years ago
|
| Just bottled. Quite light and savoury. Well balanced with fresh acidity and a steely character. Very sound reserved style Saint-Bris for near term drinking. |
| |
| Petit Chablis, 2004 |
This is made with contract grapes.
|
| Clean and pure aroma with quite a light palate, but one which sufficiently fills out in the middle and finishes attractively. Muted stony, savoury character. Very sound. From 2005. |
| |
| Chablis, 2004 |
Reserved on aroma, lemon and floral. Very pure and clinical but with pleasant minerality on the middle palate. Well balanced. Smooth and cool. Very competent. From 2006 |
| |
| Chablis, Montmain, 2004 |
Light, lifted floral aroma, not showing much. Well balanced with moderate grip. Lightly saline, but a bit unexciting. Fair finish. From 2006 |
| |
| Chablis, Vaillons, 2004 |
Floral, upright and pure. This is appley with a tight saline character and firm backbone, but also some generosity in the middle palate. Juicily intense finish. Particularly good. From 2008 |
| |
| Chablis, Les Lys, 2004 |
Although part of Vaillons, Séguier likes to vinify the fifty year old vines of Les Lys separately. The vines face North East, versus South East for Vaillon.
|
| Vibrant fruit with good depth. The middle palate is very reserved and austere. This has steely acidity, a very firm and stony profile and excellent balance. Long and mineral finish. Exceedingly correct. Particularly good to fine. From 2008 |
| |
| Chablis, Montée De Tonnerre, 2004 |
Touch of honey on the aroma - rather sleek. More grip and sheen on the palate. Power in middle and on the finish. Steely core, racy and saline. Very proper, cool and reserved and long. Meticulous winemaking. I like this. Fine. From 2008/9 |
| |
| Chablis, Vaulovent, 2004 |
This is part of Fouchaume, although in fact it abuts Preuses on the other side of the hill and has a different exposition.
|
| Very quiet on the nose, but much more expressive on the palate in terms of intensity and latent richness. Outrageously austere though, very nervy and intense. Almost crystalline on the finish. Very pure and so correct. Fine. From 2010. |
| |
| Chablis, Beauroy, 2004 |
Fèvre have 6 of the total 12 hectares of Beauroy They have 2 very different parcels which will be blended making it difficult to project the quality of the final blend, but I don't think it will be one of Fèvre's more exciting wines given the proposed larger percentage of parcel one. |
Parcel one: 4 hectares on top of the slope, South West facing with very argile soil
Lean with light manicured minerality, but slightly devoid of personality. Green apples and dry chalky finish. Fair |
Parcel two: 2 hectares on a 50% slope, south facing.
More mineral and elegant. Richer aroma, denser although very tight. Much more generous and deep with a smooth stony character. Very correct and impressive finish. Particularly good to fine. |
| |
| Chablis, Vaudesir, 2004 |
With its south exposure and early maturity, Fèvre begin the harvest with their Vaudésir.
|
| Floral, blossomy and more feminine. Lifted, good intensity and more finesse with a racy core. More delicate, subtle, poised and savoury. Not a lot of minerality at present, but I think this will come with a little bottle age. Fine. From 2010 |
| |
| Chablis, Valmur, 2004 |
Pure and savoury aroma. Reserved and austere palate. Steely and linear with depth, a glossy texture and more weight. Exceedingly neat. Very hidden. Fine, maybe very fine. From 2010/11 |
| |
| Chablis, Preuses 2004 |
Two and a half hectares; one part South East slope, the other South West giving more richness.
|
| Another secretive wine, however plenty of grip. Undeniably smart wine with lovely balance, glassy, sleek, cool and reserved. Profound with a serious finish. Made for ageing. Very fine. From 2010/11 |
| |
Chablis, Les Clos 2004 |
Four hectares on the top of the slope
|
| Dense unsprung aroma. Grip yet very sleek, more powerful and profound. Compact and complete palate. Architectural wine. Very fine. From 2012 |
| |
| Stockists |
UK: Berry Bros & Rudd; J.E. Fells; Heyman Barwell & Jones; Longford Wines; Montrachet; Freddy Price; Reid Wines; Charles Taylor Wines; Waverley Vintners.
USA:
Garnet Wines & Liquors; Seagram Chateaux & Estates; Sherry-Lehmann Inc. |
| |
| |
Domaine Corinne & Jean-Pierre Grossot |
|
This pretty estate on the edge of Fleys produces very sound wines in a rich, broad and intense style. |
| |
| Chablis, 2004 |
Lots of parcels around Chablis, Fleys and Fontenay.
|
| Vibrant, fresh aromatics. Still in cuve. Quite minerally and tight, fresh and zesty fruit. Attractive for more immediate drinking. Crisp and pure. |
| |
| Chablis, La Part Des Anges, 2004 |
| From two vineyards.
|
| Vibrant and fruity aromatics. This has a more weight and grip and a little more terroir character. Very attractive. From 2006 |
| |
| Chablis, Côte De Troëmes, 2004 |
Very pure and bright. Vigorous wine with grippy acidity, medium body, neatly made and slightly stony. Attractive to good. From 2007. |
| |
Chablis, Fourchaume , 2004 |
Light aromatics, not showing too much, lower toned. Only cuve, no wood. Broader, but still linear profile. Smooth, slightly creamy and compact. The finish is surprisingly sustained. Very good. From 2007 |
| |
| Chablis, Fourneaux, 2004 |
600 litre casks of old wood. Wood doesn't show on the aroma which is pure and vibrant fruit and a touch floral and appley. Charming lifted fruit on the palate. There is a creamy texture, richness and breadth with a counterpoint of steeliness. Sensitive use of battonage used here. Good follow though. Very good. From 2007 |
| |
| Chablis, Vaucoupin, 2004 |
Very new and estery with lively, pure fruit. This is only in cuve, no wood, however there is a certain amount of careful battonage at racking. The palate is lower-toned and broad, a touch fennel and very vigorous. Attractive and slightly savoury finish. Good. 3 years. |
| |
| Chablis, Mont De Milieu, 2004 |
Pure vibrant esters. Energetic attack and a juicy, zesty backbone to this wine. Good grip and a nervy, linear structure to a fine tight finish. Very classic and pure. Particularly good. However this will be blended with one third of wine aged in barrel, so the character will change. |
| |
| Stockists |
UK: Enotria Winecellar; Ian G. Howe; Lay & Wheeler; Liberty Wines (As Domaine Perchaud); O.W. Loeb & Co; La Vigneronne.
USA:
Kysela Pere & Fils; World Wine Source. |
| |
| |
|
| Jean-Bernard Marchive considers 2004 very typical of the appellation. Although he was initially concerned with the high levels of malic acidity, after the malolactic fermentation he felt happy with the balance. I found this a stimulating tasting. Lots of minerality and distinctive terroir character. Distinctive wine. |
| |
| Petit Chablis, 2004 |
| Thirty-five year old vines. |
| Vervy fruit, pure aromatics, good concentration for Petit Chablis. It has a vibrant citrus backbone and an attractive finish. Delivers a lot for a little wine. From 2006. |
| |
| Chablis, 2004 |
| Remarkably powdery and floral with most attractive intensity and minerality. Saline,taut palate. Very classic, pure and delicious Chablis. From 2007 |
| |
| Chablis, Van De Vey, 2004 |
| Elegant, floral and lifted with lovely linear palate and limey acidity. Wet stone, reserve and gravelly persistence. Delicious terroir wine. Fine quality for this level. From 2007/8 |
| |
| Chablis, Vieilles Vignes, Tour de Roys, 2004 |
| Fifty percent each in tank and barrels. Sample blend. Barrels from 1999-2003. 50 year old vines. |
| More luscious given the wood and lees but the concentrated fruit just swallows it up. Very glossy attack and a sleek texture with racy acidity and lots of vivacity. Juicy long finish. Particularly good. From 2008 |
| |
| Chablis, Côte De Lechet, 2004 |
| The vines are 25-35 years old. |
| Rather more feminine aroma, floral, greengage with a touch of gunflint. Concentrated austere appley fruit with steely intensity and very taut structure. Perisitent chalky finish. A really palate stimulating wine. Fine to very fine. From 2008/09. |
| |
| Chablis, Montmains, Vieilles Vignes, 2004 |
| Vines are 45-50 years old. |
| Slightly lower toned and gravely. Finely tuned and straight as a die with long linear finish. Flinty and excellent grip. Nervous. Love this style. Fine to very fine Montmains. From 2010 |
| |
| Chablis, Fourchaume, 2004 |
| Slightly softer and more generous aromatics with a plumper, more opulent palate, but the steely backbone balances the round fruit which defines this wine. Fuller finish. Particularly good. 2008/9 |
| |
| Chablis, Vaudésir, 2004 |
| Pear-like, quite rich but floral fruit. Very upright and intense. Bright citrus acidity, very refreshing and excellent depth. Rather beautiful wine with very floral notes on the palate. Very poised, elegant and stony. Long and lovely finish. Very fine to outstanding. From 2010 |
| |
| Chablis, Les Clos, 2004 |
| 100% in barrel, which are one to two years old. It remains there for between 8 -10 months and is then put in tank. |
| Oak evident on the nose, rather baroque and powerful, but the rich and concentrated fruit dominates. Sumptuous and glossy, broad and compact with a long sleek finish. Although this is a very serious wine, for my taste the Vaudésir has more flair. Very fine to outstanding. From 2010 |
| |
| Stockists |
UK agent: Charles Hawkins; Berry Bros & Rudd; Bordeaux Direct; Hall Batson & Co.; Howells of Bristol; Longford Wines; Montrachet; The New London Wine Ltd.; Freddy Price; Michael Ruddock Wines; Edward Sheldon; T & W Wines Ltd.; Charles Taylor Wines; Wine Bin Ends Ltd.; The Wine Society.
USA: International Gourmet Corp; Monsieur Touton Selection Ltd.; The Wine Messenger. |
| |
|
| Bernard Legland is a very unassuming man making lovely, very classic Chablis. They are not profound wines for long aging, but fresh glassy clear wines with excellent typicity for the short and medium term. Benchmark Petit Chablis and Chablis. Legand inoculates and always does malolactic fermentation. He normally keeps the wine on fine lees and bottles from May to the following January for the premier cru. In 2004 he was not so pleased with the quality of the lees, so he separated them. |
| |
| Petit Chablis, 2004 |
| This comes form one parcel in Préhy and the age of the vines is 4 to 18 years. |
| Very mineral aromatics. Pure and direct palate. Tight, stony, racy with fine fruit, lime-like acidity and a steely finsh. Like this a lot. Fine quality Petit Chablis. From 2006 |
| |
| Chablis, 2004 |
| The Chablis is made of 15 parcels from Préhy, Chablis and Courgis, and the age of the vines is 20 years on average. |
| More richness on the nose with all the minerality of the above. Direct and saline, taut and stony, with a tight mineral finsh and excellent nervosity. Fine quality Chablis. From 06/7 |
| |
| Chablis, Montmains, 2004 |
| Intense, perfumed with a tad more polish. Good attack. More depth on middle palate and follows through very tight, racy and mineral. Lovely direct, linear style executed with flair. Lighter style, but particularly good to fine. From 2007. |
| |
| Chablis, Côtes De Jouan, 2004 |
| Very floral, totally different and not as good as the Montmains. Softer, more feminine palate, a little less focused and more gentle, with a delicate flowery finish. Pretty. From 2006 |
| |
| Stockists |
UK: Bibendum; Continental & Overseas Wines; House of Townsend; Ian G. Howe; Great Western; Peter Watts.
USA: Lionstone International. |
| |
| |
|
| This is 'high maintenance' wine, raised in luxury, with no expense spared. The domaine oozes an ambience of affluence. Jean-Louis Michel makes refined, glossily mineral wines, not in the nervy, edgy Chablis genre. The wines are composed, poised and smooth. Very fine quality and consistency. In contrast with his rather grand wine Michel himself is delightfully down to earth and eager to please. His assistant had overlooked my early visit and was not prepared when I arrived, so Michel scurried around his immaculate cellars pulling out the samples with great good humour. He uses no wood, preferring not to mask the terroir. The glossy character is from the quality fruit alone. |
| |
| Petit Chablis, 2004 |
| Good intensity. Delicate, silky and a touch floral. Very well balanced. Firmness and good grip for a little wine. Lovely fresh minerality. Particularly good Petit Chablis. From 2006/7 |
| |
| Chablis, 2004 |
| More intensity, verve and concentration on aroma. Fruit driven, with a delicious purity. Silky and a touch racy. Lighter version of the bigger wines...showing good domaine style. Very refreshing. Lovely village wine. From 2007 |
| |
| Chablis, Vaillons, 2004 |
| Big step up in quality. Intense aroma of oyster-shell and lime blossom. Well structured, zesty, racy. Good typcity, austere, but rounded and smooth. More stony than steely. Powerful and persistent finish. Particularly good. From 2008 |
| |
| Chablis, Montmains, 2004 |
| More perfumed and upright than the Vaillons on the aroma. More profound on palate too. Steely core and flinty notes. Elegance and power with grunt and minerality. Good grip. This is text book tipicité from a top notch Montmains. Very fine. From 2010. |
| |
| Chablis, Fourchaume, 2004 |
| Immediatly seductive and rich on the nose. Appealing honey and mineral with lovely purity. Very silky, elegant, refined wine with an engaging plumpness to middle palate. A well-groomed rounder profile, warmer and more accessible with juicy acidity and a long opulent finish. Probably fine. From 2012 |
| |
| Chablis, Montée De Tonnerre, 2004 |
| Quite a hidden aroma, but with evident tautness and gravely character. Gloss and power, dense and profound. Excellent structure with lots of grip on back palate. Not as sexy and upfront as the Fourchaume, but a more sophisticated and reserved profile. From 2010/12 Very fine to outstanding. |
| |
| Chablis, Vaudésir, 2004 |
| Perfumed with a pronounced floral aroma, tight and blossomy. Racy mineral, steely core and a linear shape. This combines depth with grace. It's sleek, tight and intense and has great finesse. Long piano wire finish. Outstanding. From 2012 |
| |
| Chablis, Grenouilles, 2004 |
| Earthy and compact on the aroma in comparison with Vaudésir. Rich strike, ample body and concentrated fruit. Dense middle palate and firm structure. Complex and layered with a serious finish, but lacks the refinement of the best of Michel's wine. Particularly good/fine. From 2010 |
| |
| Chablis, Les Clos, 2004 |
| Taut with unsprung potential on the aroma and a powerful strike on the palate. Epitomises the glossy textural style of this winemaker. It is reserved, poised and elegant yet enormously intense and pure. Steely backbone and grip cloaked with gorgeous fruit. Very profound. Outstanding quality. From 2012 |
| |
| Stockists |
UK: Berry Bros & Rudd; Corney & Barrow; Dreyfus Ashby & Co. Ltd.; Enotria Winecellars; Findlater Mackie; Fortnum & Mason; Haynes & Clark; Ian G. Howe; O.W. Loeb & Co. Reid Wines; Thresher Group; The Wine Society.
USA: Burgundy Wine Co.; Calvert Woodley; Garnet Wines & Liquors; Vineyard Brands Inc. |
| |
| |
Domaine Christian Moreau Père & Fils |
|
| Christian Moreau began this venture with his son Fabien after retrieving the family vineyards leased to Ets J. Moreau. Christian is keen that the limelight should fall on his talented, but rather shy son who is the winemaker. Fabien gained experience working in New Zealand for Ngatarawa, but highlights his time with Domaine Chevalier. Christian comments, "Fabien is a maniac, he works so fastidiously." |
| |
| Delighted and evidently somewhat relieved that one of his children has followed him into the wine trade, he is proud of his son's first vintages. In their shared drive for quality, Christian has fulfilled Fabien's wish list of expensive toys, including two new presses. He has also conceded his staunchly negative position on wood. Fabien is an oak believer for use on premier and grand cru and as he is effectively in charge of the show, oak is now very much in use. Wood and great kit apart, Fabien also pays great attention to work in the vineyard including debudding the vines to keep the yields low and hand picking. His aim? "To make top quality wine at a reasonable price." |
| |
| Chablis , 2004 |
| Fresh and direct fruit. Fair quality. |
| |
| Chablis, Vaillons, 2004 |
| Forty-five to fifty year old vines. Thirty-five percent 1-3 year old oak and 5 percent new. |
| Pure and flowery on the nose, touch of wax and wet stone. Good attack and a creamy textured palate, quite ample, with firm acidity and stony notes. Good. From 2006 |
| |
| Chablis, Vaillons, Cuvée Guy Moreau, 2004 |
| This is a special cuvée of 1 hectare. Guy Moreau, Christian's father planted the vines 74 years old. |
| More depth and complexity on the aroma, floral, but also saline. Attractive linear palate with touch of oyster character. This is an attractive wine with good typicity. From 2007 |
| |
| Chablis, Vaudesir, 2004 |
| Light and lifted aroma. Moreau cut the yields back to 35hl/hl to concentrate the young vines. Very attractive floral character, well balanced, but just a little lacking in depth and a bit short. The wood is a bit too apparent on the finish. From 2006 |
| |
| Chablis, Blanchots, 2004 |
| Moreau have just 10 ares. It is put into 100% oak. |
| Generous aroma, golden, nutty and creamy. Decent oystershell minerality, ample, but with reasonable tautness to middle palate. The wood firms up the structure. Slightly disappointing finsh. At most very good. From 2007 |
| |
| Chablis, Valmur, 2004 |
| Intense and minerally, but also quite glossy and rich. Elegantly rounded and creamy palate with good sheen and juicy acidity, yet with compact weigh and opulence in the middle palate and firm minerality. The wood handling is most successful here. Particularly good to fine. From 2009 |
| |
| Chablis, Les Clos, 2004 |
| Full aroma, pure and slightly crystalline. Good attack. Very rounded, complete palate, with taut acidity and grip and very distinct oyster/saline character which carries onto the long finish. Fine. From 2010/12. |
| |
| Chablis, 2003 |
| Nutty and very golden. Smoky, saline character, modest acidity and nutty, slightly exotic palate. Pleasant, but drink up. |
| |
| Chablis, Vaillons, 2003 |
| Crystallised fruit, full an rich and generous. Sleek and generous to begin with, but a slightly roasted flavour on the finish. Sound. Drink now and for a couple of years. |
| |
| Chablis, Vaillons, Cuvée Guy Moreau, 2003 |
| The deep roots, which I am told penetrate to 7 metres, meant that these vines suffered less than most. Very exotic, buttery and rich, notes of lime and cashew. Equally indulgent palate, with saline minerality. Very good. Drink soon 2005/6 and over the short term. |
| |
| Chablis, Vaudesir, 2003 |
| Lighter, more floral and lemony, touch of honey. Delicate, not as deep as Vaillons. Light saline character and apricot honeyed notes. A little short. It's not going anywhere. |
| |
| Chablis, Blanchots, 2003 |
| Broader, but also denser in the middle palate with a firm, gravel character. A little short. Unctuous now, if a little shallow. Not a keeper |
| |
| Chablis, Valmur, 2003 |
| Very enticing bouquet, rich, decadent with aromas of toast and melted butter. Generous palate, broad and rounded with decent acidity, although there is a bit of a dip in the middle. Moderate finish, but regally a very seductive, ripe wine. Fine. Delicious now, but could be kept for the short term. |
| |
| Chablis, Les Clos, 2003 |
| Glossy and opulent. More contained on the bouquet than the Valmur. More complete. Finish is finer and longer. Very fine. From 2007/8 |
| |
| Chablis, Clos Des Hospices, 2003 |
| Very nutty, waxy rich, sleek and spherical palate. Particularly good. From 2007 |
| |
| Stockists |
UK: Gunson Fine Wines Ltd; Thorman Hunt & Co
USA: Frederick Wildman. |
| |
| |
|
| This family has been growing grapes in Chablis since the C17th. Stéphane Moreau took over in 1991 and immediately began bottling his own wine. He is young, undoubtedly talented and bubbles with energy. His sense of humour and lively spirit shines though his wines which are vibrant, good natured, and belie something more serious going on underneath. Lovely, clear and pure style. |
| |
| In 2002 and 2003 Moreau bought himself two new pneumatic presses and is sure that the careful whole bunch pressing he uses helps account for the purity of his wine. He has just invested in a new cuvérie so he can bottle later and do a natural and longer stabilization. He has been building his business slowly, ploughing back the profit. |
| |
| One of the first things he invested in was temperature control. He ferments at 21/22 degrees and is adamant that anything cooler would suppress terroir character. In 1999 he invested in barrels - one for every 3000 litres of wine. It's evident he would love to do more, but it's a matter of cash. The advantage of slow growth, however frustrating, is the time it allows for the results of experiments to truly be assessed. For example Moreau stopped battonage after disappointingly results in 1996 and 1999. |
| |
| The premier cru vineyards were all planted by his grandfather. |
| |
| Petit Chablis, 2004 |
| The fruit is from Cougis. Vibrant, zesty and lime-like with fresh acidity. Sound. Will bottle in August. For immedaite drinking. |
| |
| Chablis, Vieilles Vignes, 2004 |
| Moreau has 1 hectare in Les Pargues and likes to vinify parcel by parcel. |
| Soft and flowery aroma with a light palate, relatively racy acidity and some minerality on the finsh. Very pretty. From From 2005/6 |
| |
| Chablis, Vaillons, 2004 |
| This is produced in tank and barrel. |
| More weight and depth with juicy minerality. Saline and flinty, also some earthy breadth. Very well balanced and although the wood is apparent on the palate, it does not dominate. Very good. From 2008. |
| |
| Chablis, Montmains, 2004 |
| Vibrant, energetic aroma. Low toned and slightly diffuse palate does not live up to the promise. Fair. From 2006 |
| |
| Chablis, Les Forêts, 2004 |
| Lively and elegant, very pure. Really lovely fruit, floral and appley, delicate and poised with quite soft, fruity acidity. A zesty long finish and just a glimpse of steel. Particularly good to fine. From 2009 |
| |
| Chablis, Montée De Tonnerre, 2004 |
| Fragrant. Fine fruit, but defined by a racy and steely character. It shows a flinty, edgy nervosity with linear profile and mineral finish. Very pure. The wood is noticeable, but well handled. Fine to very fine and my favourite wine here. From 2010 |
| |
| Chablis, Valmur, 2004 |
| Rather rich and more generous. Plumper body and perhaps a more compact middle palate, less minerality than the Montée de Tonnerre, more toned muscle and sleek texture. The wood supporting the structure is more apparent. Good layering. Very good follow though with some minerality. Fine. From 2009 |
| |
| Stockists |
| UK: The Wine Society, Loeb, Tanners, Lee and Sandeman
USA: Christopher Cannon |
| |
| |
|
| Laurent and Christophe Pinson worked with their grandfather until he retired in 1987. Laurent says they blend new techniques with traditional philosophy in their aim to produce wine of richness and power with minerality. They have introduced some new oak into the grand cru and a smidgen into the premier cru, "only to shape the wine," says Laurent. He evidently likes to experiment and is working with lees and battonage, "to give more gras." He thinks that perhaps the battaonge makes his wines rather closed to begin with, but better for ageing. He also uses microbullage. The domaine style is rich, marked by oak and generous. Equally there is no lack of firm structure and terroir definition. Good consistency of quality. |
| |
| Chablis, 2004 |
| This was bottled one month ago and is a blend of fruit from 5 parcels, the majority sited between Montmains and Vaillons. Pinson takes a maximum of 50 hl/ha on average for Chablis and this is reflected in the decent concentration of this wine. |
| Attractive, fruity aromas. Good attack and grip for a Chablis, fruity but also quite austere, with touch of steel on the backbone. Sound. From 2006/7 |
| |
| Chablis, Vaillons, 2004 |
| This is from 8 year old vines. There are just five barrels of Vaillons. The fermentation and malolactic take place in 5 year old barrels, and after the malolactic the wine is transferred to older barrels. This is a slightly more 'worked wine' with nutty notes from the battonage and a warm brioche aroma. Quite accessible. Rounded, but decent intensity and firmness of the core for relatively young vines. Good. From 2006/7 |
| |
| Chablis, Vaugirauts , 2004 |
| This is from a small parcel 0.34 of a hectare. The whole of this premier cru is only 3 hectares. |
| More lifted on the aroma with white flowers and greengages, quite forward. Good attack, grip and balance. Very energetic with plenty of minerality. Particularly good. From 2006/7 |
| |
| Chablis, Les Forêts, 2004 |
| Five and six year old wood is used for maturation. |
| Seductive and stony, wet stone, rather smooth. Top notes of white flowers. Decent grip and a tense minerally follow through. Well structured wine, more linear than Vaillons, but more ample than the Montmains and with a creamier texture. Partcularly good. From 2007/8 |
| |
| Chablis, Montmains, 2004 |
| Rather an elegant aroma, mineral upright and reserved with appley fruit. Touch of wood with a silky sheen on the entry, fine, creamy powerdery texture and a well rounded middle palate. Firm backbone and a persistent flinty finsh. This is a very attractive, glossy and mineral Montmains. Particularly good to fine. From 2008 |
| |
| Chablis, Mont De Milieu, 2004 |
| Four year old wood used here. |
| Very perfumed and floral aroma followed by a rather floral first impression on the palate. This becomes more chalky and mineral with fine racy acidity, lots of verve and a vibrant long finsh with plenty of fruit. Very good intensity and breadth, layered, rich and with a firm structure for ageing. Particularly good to fine. From 2010 |
| |
| Chablis, Les Clos, 2004 |
| The three-year-old oak is very well matched to the depth and quality of fruit. |
| Dense, rich, smooth aroma with lots of unsprung potential, yet also lifted and elegant. Velvety texture, sumptuous, honeyed and ample in the middle palate, yet taut and grippy on the back palate. Power and elegance. Slippery, wet, smooth stone. Complex wine with a powerful finish. Fine. From 2010 |
| |
| Stockists |
UK: Bibendum; Europvin; Lea & Sandeman; O.W. Loeb; Majestic Wine Warehouse; Christopher Piper Wines; Tanners; The Wine Society.
USA: Petit Pois Corp; Michael Skurnik Wines Inc.; Wine Warehouse. |
| |
| |
|
| Bernard Raveneau produces thoroughbred Chablis. The domaine style is sleek and glossy, yet very steely and pure. The wine has verve and pace. It ages a second year in cask and will need time in bottle to reveal its full potential. Raveneau tastes at a breakneck speed. My laptop was practically smoking. (Thank heavens for long practice at timed MW style tasting). Only towards the end of the tasting did he relax and start speaking about his wine. His experiments with Blanchots are interesting (see below). As is often the case with the very best growers, he is modest and identifies both his weaknesses and his strengths. |
| |
| Chablis, Montmains, 2004 |
| On the lees at the moment and a bit reduced, but some citrus aromatics showing. Tight steely fruit on the palate, racy and taut. Sleek, linear structure and long saline finish. Particularly good. 2010 |
| |
| Chablis, Montmains, 200 3 |
| Tasted in May. Bottled in June. Richness of warm straw on the aroma. Intense, tight palate, ripe fruit balanced with firm acidity. Steely core and very polished. Long and powerful finish. Fine. From 2008 |
| |
| Chablis, Vaillons, 2004 |
| No comment on aroma which was somewhat masked by some SO2 for it had just been racked and sulphured. Big structure, spherical, yet mineral, very smart and glossy. It has the edge of richness on Montmains. It has a compact mid-palate and a more polished steel character. Lovely fruit and a long succulent finish. Particularly good to fine From 2008/9. |
| |
| Chablis, Vaillons, 2003 |
| Very reserved on the nose. Rather polished palate, spherical, but with excellent grip and a very steely and profound finish. Particularly good. From 2008 |
| |
| Chablis, Butteaux, 2004 |
| Tight aroma with fennel, herbs and seaweed, but also breadth. Wider palate than typical of Raveneau's other cru, but tightens in and has a core of steely aniseed. Both breadth and depth here. Pure, long saline finish. Fine. From 2008/9 |
| |
| Chablis, Butteaux, 2003 |
| Richness of ripe fennel; warmer aromas. Supple first impression which opens to quite a broad palate, ample middle with good density and smooth stone character. Powerful buttery finish. Fine. From 2007 |
| |
| Chablis, Montée De Tonnerre, 2004 |
| Lovely steely wine with racy lines. Long and fluid with a piano wire finish. Excellent equilibrium. Very fine to outstanding. |
| |
| Chablis, Blanchots, 2004 |
| Currently Raveneaux is experimenting with fermenting Blanchots in two year old wood. He says he's not exactly not sure why, however the wine itself is perhaps more revealing. Blanchots has the least interesting structure of Ravneau's grand cru wine. It's floral, rounded, quite gentle and even a bit diffuse at the edges. |
| The oak shows on the aroma, but doesn't dominate. However it is much more apparent on the palate and in this case contributes structure and edges to Blanchot's softness. Perhaps this will work. The fruit carries the wood at the moment, although the oak shows up last up on the finish. Better acidity (than 2003) gives this vintage the necessary structure and raciness to save the effect from being rather chunky. |
| |
| Chablis, Blanchots, 200 3 |
| Floral, wet stone and a touch herbal. Rounded, softer without the density of the other wine, gentler and more powdery than steely, and a softer although long finish. Not quite as profound or defined as one would like. From 2007 |
| |
| Chablis, Valmur, 2004 |
| Leashed power on the aroma. Comes in with a punch on the palate. Very powerful and penetrating wine which is slightly showy. It's undoubtedly concentrated and has a touch of muscularity. Dense and rich, but with lots of steel. Very classic, just more bullish than sophisticated at this stage. This has shoulders. Fine.From 2010/12 |
| |
| Chablis, Valmur, 2003 |
| Punchy and dense aroma, somewhat opulent and exotic. Spherical, glossy palate with broad shoulders. Slightly muscular, but combines steely minerality with power. Fine. From 2008/9 |
| |
| Chablis, Les Clos, 2004 |
| Reduced aroma. Lots of latent power here. Very architectural, complex and polished. Intensely steely and massive grip. Complete wine with a lot of energy and a fuel injected finish. Outstanding From 2012 |
| |
| Chablis, Les Clos, 2003 |
| Power and reserve on the aroma. High gloss. Touch of spice, and lifted notes. Serious attack and grip. Rich, but tight and unsprung. Mouth coating texture with power and density. Steely core and finish. Outstanding. From 2010/12 |
| |
| Stockists |
UK: John Armit Wines; Haynes, Hanson & Clark; Raeburn
USA: Burgundy Wine Co. Ltd.; Hi-Time Wine Cellars; Kermit Lynch |
| |
| |
|
| Wine with lovely acidity and excellent ageing potential. Intelligent and considered winemaking here. The Servin family have been growers in Chablis for more than 300 years. François Servin's grandfather was solely a grower. Previous generations combined vines with other professions given the risk of frost. His great grandfather was also a cooper. |
| |
| Servin is keen to keep "the original style of Chablis," which he says is difficult as customers' palates have changed. This applies in particular to the question of accessibility versus ageing. His solution is to produce a Petit Chablis and Chablis for immediate drinking. As a youngster he tasted many old vintages with his grandfather and is adamant that grand cru Chablis should be made in the traditional way, should not be touched for three to four years, should drink from 5-6 years and keep for 12-15. Top wines, he argues, have the potential to mature over several decades. |
| |
| Servin is concerned about the shift he has noticed over the past ten years to technology and wonders if it is all necessary. "Today," he says, "people are judged too much on being good viticulturalists or winemakers and not on whether they make good wine. The most important thing is the taste in the bottle." |
| |
| Petit Chablis, 2004 |
| The vines are found on the plateau above the grand crus. Nutty and smooth aroma. Good intensity, very zesty, energetic and fresh with good grip and finish. Over performs for Petit Chablis. Impressive. Drink now and for a couple of years. |
| |
| Chablis, 2004 |
| Nutty, peachy and glossy aroma. Broad, bit of wet pebble and moderately compact. Very typical. Good. From 2005 |
| |
| Chablis, Cuvée Massalle, 2004
|